Tools for Working Wood

 Joel's Blog at Tools for Working Wood

Too Much of a Muchness  

10/26/2016

The three Stanley scraper planes in the picture above are part of my tool collection and largely unused. I have two more that didn't make it into the shot - a No. 80 and another No. 12 1/2. The No. 80 was purchased in the 1970's for use but I haven't used it in years. I have no idea where it is. My other 12 1/2 gets occasional use.

Scraper planes were a lot more popular in the days before sandpaper became ubiquitous. Cabinet scrapers, and scraper planes if you have a lot of scraping to do, are the best way to smooth patchy grain, knots, and other crazy grain features without doing a lot of sanding. Sanding does cover a multitude of sins, and for most people that what one does and that's it. But for many of you wanting a planed finish, scraper planes still have a place in the shop. Instrument makers who need to take off fractions of a shaving very carefully also have a call for scrapers.

But can anyone explain to me why the Stanley Catalogue No. 34 lists eleven different models including a glue scraper? (BTW that glue scraper is very handy and the Kunz version isn't bad either.)

Tool collectors might need every model of every plane. Tool users don't. Or at least I can't figure out why they would.

The interesting question is why Stanley decided to manufacture all these different versions. It certainly makes sense for an non-adjustable version and an adjustable version. But a plain one (No. 12) and a Rosewood bottomed one (12 1/2 in picture) - does it matter?

Of course the reason is that Stanley, like any large company, wanted to have a tool for every segment of the market. You want the lowest cost? Get the No. 80. You want to treat yourself to the top of the line? Get the 12 1/2. A small one handed scraper plane - for smaller work? The 212 fits the bill perfectly. But all these planes do exactly the same thing. The different models exist primarily to satisfy the needs of the manufacturer, not, except in very rare cases, the end user (you).

The same is true of bench planes. They're conveniently numbered from 1 to 8. You might want a smooth plane (3-4), and a long plane (6-8) ( see last blog). Some people also like the "jack" length found in the "5" family. One per group is easy to justify from a user standpoint. After that, I think you enter collector territory. In my particular case, very early on I realized that If I admitted I was a collector I didn't need to sharpen all the tools I owned, just the ones I used. This saved oodles of time and let me keep expanding my collection guilt free.

Picture: Upper left: No. 112. Right: No. 12 1/2. Lower left: No. 81.

Stanley no longer makes the No. 80, but we stock a usable, pretty decent version by Kunz. Most Stanley scraper planes were manufactured in large numbers and are readily available on the used market. We stock replacement blades by Ron Hock for most models which are heavier, better made, and perform better than the original blades.

Tags:Unclassified
Comments: 4
10/26/2016Richard 
Too much?
10/26/2016Morgan 
Interesting article. I have several No. 5 planes, but I use them differently - mind you they are all yardsale finds, except the low angle Lie Nielson I got as a Christmas present.

I have one set up to be my shooting board plane, one set up with some camber and a big mouth, and one set up as probably closer to a smoothing plane than I should admit (I have a perfectly good smoothing plane, but I still grab this No.5..) It's the only plane I have more than one of, the rest being a block plane, a No. 4, and a No.8.
10/27/2016Charley 
Great article. I will admit that I am a sudo collector. I have every thing in the stanly plane line except a #1. I use them all. I also have both the 80 and the 112 scraper planes. I keep the 112 for shop use and the 80 in my finish carpentry tool box for job sites. I love the things. The finish a good scraper gives is so superior to sandpaper. As for the planes, I carry a No 3 for field use and mostly use the 41/2 in the shop. My favorite jack plane is a 5 1/2. It is my go to jack for the shop. I have a 5 in my field tool box. I seldom use the 6 or 7 but when I hang doors the 8 is the work horse I go for. I will admit that I actually have multiples of some of the planes. In my opinion the 5 1/4 is weird but since it was a shop class plane I have used them to teach plane fundamentals to promising apprentices.
10/27/2016Bruce Helart 
I own the LN version of the No112 as well as the LN small scraping plane. Earlier this year I made a bed with 32 rectangular spindles in the headboard. They were made of figured cherry. Scraping them turned out to be the perfect way to get a finished surface before glue-up. It took a while and some fiddling but once I got those two scrapers tuned the work went well and I find myself using those two tools more frequently ever since. The small on especially is easy to use, push or pull use with one hand.
Comments are closed.
The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the blog's author and guests and in no way reflect the views of Tools for Working Wood.
Subscribe
 Joel's Blog
 Video Roundup
 Classes & Events
 Built-It Blog
 Work Magazine
Recent Blogs:
Spooncarving and News - 03/29/2017
How to Use a Marking or Mortise Gauge (reprise) - 03/22/2017
How to Learn to Carve in the Modern Age - The Online Approach - 03/15/2017
Mitre Planes and the Finest of Mouths: Why? What Evidence? What to Look for When Shopping for Mitre and Shoulder Planes - 03/08/2017
Context! - 03/01/2017
Mitre Planes and an Observation about Maker's Marks - 02/22/2017
How To Grind Part 6 - How to Repair a Damaged Edge Without Burning the Steel - 02/08/2017
How To Grind: Part 5 - Grinding the Hollow - 02/01/2017
How To Grind: Part 4 - Dressing Your Grinding Wheel for Cool Running, Balance, and Convexity - 01/25/2017
How To Grind Part 3 - Grinding Wheel Chemistry and Nomenclature - 01/19/2017
How To Grind Part 2 - The Technology of Grinding -, Grinders, and Grinding Wheels - 01/11/2017
How To Grind - Part 1 - When To Grind - 01/04/2017
Happy New Year, A Great Experience, Ideas for the New Year, & News - 12/28/2016
Nail - 12/21/2016
The Gramercy Tools Saw Etch Story - 12/14/2016
Hayward vs Hasluck, Ellis, & Jones - 12/07/2016
A Failure to Communicate - 11/30/2016
Guest Blogger: Chris Pye - Get A Grip - 11/23/2016
New For The Fall and Other News - 11/16/2016
New Tools - Fall 2016 - 11/02/2016
Older Entries...