Menushopping cart
Tools for Working Wood
Invest in your craft. Invest in yourself.

 Joel's Blog

Blasts from the Past - Reimagined - and Made For the Future

05/15/2015

There still is a lot of innovation in hand tool design - innovation that ranges from tweaks to completely new approaches in design and manufacture. Modern makers of tools, all of us, are using new materials and new manufacturing techniques to advance tool performance and tool appearance. The hand tool innovators of the 19th century did the same and did their best to industrialize handtool manufacture and wring the most performance from human-powered machinery. They did a great job. It's always been the philosophy at TFWW to look to the past for direction, and then push forward using the advantages we have today. Two years ago, at the first Handworks show in Amana, Iowa, we got a chance to see a real Montague-Woodrough handsaw. The saw, made by a small competitor of the giant saw companies of the time (Disston, Atkins & Simmonds), had an innovative tooth design that ripped brilliantly, crosscut smoothly in hardwood, and while looking bizarre, was no more difficult to sharpen by hand than any other good saw. It probably didn't succeed in the marketplace due to its lack of distribution and the difficulty of sharpening it using the machines available at the time.

We are closing the circle today, and it is fitting that we are introducing the BT&C hardware store saw with our version of the Montague-Woodrough tooth pattern at Handworks 2015. (The saw will be available on our website shortly after we return from the show and finish catalog photography and related things).

The tooth pattern of our saw was inspired by the Montague-Woodrough saw, but isn't identical. We have the benefit of studying what they did so we can move forward. We did a lot of prototyping and we think our tooth pattern has some advantages over the original. We also added a few other 19th century innovations. The saw cuts like a demon and also functions as a pretty accurate square; ruler; protractor; layout guide for dovetails; and many other tools. The idea of using a saw for layout is of course a 19th century idea, but it never caught on much and was hard to manufacture reliably. The graphic details on the saw are inspired by the mid 20th century machine tools in our workshop and the background texture (you can't really etch a flat surface evenly, and it would wear too fast too) takes its original design from an 18th century leather instrument case.

But this is a high tech 21st century saw. Really. The detailed etches on each side of the saw are accurate and clear to read. The black color of the etch is below the surface of the saw and will last for years. In the 19th century, makers could not effectively etch that amount of detail. In the 20th century, the shallow electo-etch that was popular would wear off over time and even initially rarely had the detail needed. In the 21st century, we use a state-of-the-art etching mask, lots of computer time and precision in punching to register the blade and pattern correctly from each side of the saw. Unlike the fancy square saws of the 1900's, these saws can be made to a precise standard at reasonable, if not rock-bottom, price. In the USA.

The end result is a saw that you would want around the house or shop. A saw that you might take with you on the road. A saw with a comfortable full sized wood handle, that cuts fast, but is short enough (16" cutting length) to carry around without damage. A toolbox kit, an all-around saw, a household saw. You know that saw your dad had, that he got from his dad, who got it at the local hardware store a long time ago. The saw that he used for everything. You just wish it was a better saw. This one is. We also wanted to make it versatile so you don't have to go around with a kit of tools just to cut a square line or measure off a few inches on a board or cut at an angle.

When we were first discussing the concept for this saw, we referred to it as "the hardware store saw" because that was our frame of reference: the useful saw you get at any hardware store. We figured we'd call it something different later on but the name stuck, so Hardware Store Saw it is.

Here are a few pictures. In the next weeks we will release the saw to the world. We hope you like it. I'll be writing more material about the engineering and manufacturing of the saw, because for all that it's a hand saw with 19th century roots, it really is high-tech. High-tech for what a 19th century saw can do, and high-tech in some areas even for 21st century manufacturing.


Join the conversation
05/15/2015 Bob Rozaieski http://bobrozaieski.com
Wow! Nice. Glad to see something a bit different and somewhat outside the box of Disston reproductions. The tooth pattern looks quite interesting. I look forward to trying one of them. Any particular reason you went with 16" instead of something just a bit longer like 18" or 20"?
05/15/2015 Adam
Congrats! Looks like a very sturdy, well made tool!
05/15/2015 Gilgaron http://www.woodworkingchat.com
This looks really neat, I think doing things like this has the benefit of promoting hand tools for their fit to purpose rather than merely being anachronistic for fun. This also seems like it'd make a good present for a casual DIYer versus a dovetail saw only some would properly appreciate.
05/15/2015 Daniel Burgoyne
Wonderful! I congratulate you and your team on this achievement. Definitely one I will want as soon as they are available. Wish you the best success. Daniel
05/15/2015 Nate Harold
THis nails it for me. I've wanted a no-back saw but didn't want to buy a fleet of them in cross-cut and rip flavors - I don't need them that often.

I'm in.
05/15/2015 Nate
Awesome! Something that has been lacking from the market for a long while. Are the teeth impulse hardened? This could make it a real all-purpose bang around saw.
05/15/2015 Steven
Those spaced notches are reminiscent of the gullets on a bandsaw blade or even on a tablesaw blade. What function or purpose do they serve on your BT&C saw? What type of steel and thickness is the saw blade plate? What is the kerf cut width? I'm sure all these details will come out at some point. It is interesting that the saw both rips and crosscuts well but you consider it to be a general purpose household saw, like the saw dad and granddad had. Would a framer or cabinetmaker want one? The saw looks very interesting!
05/15/2015 Brian L.
Will this be the first of a line of handsaws(crosses fingers)?
05/15/2015 Bob Groh
A bit off this topic (the new saw) but did you ever finish your looksee at diamond sharpening stones? I got a DMT duo for Christmas and, while delighted with the speed, the finish on the blade is a bit underwhelming (as you pointed out). So I need to finish up on water stones. Ah, well, an ongoing journey.
05/15/2015 Bruce
Put my name on the pre-order list. Can I give you VISA info now?
05/15/2015 James Gallie Marine Repair
I am looking forward to giving this saw and it's design a good hard test. I like the size as so many cuts these days are powered with AC or DC. My longer saw's stay in shop, rarely in use unless I've a point to make. The shorter saw that I field generally is a Sandvik/Bacho or one of many of my salvaged and cut down versions of the classic's. I hope your Team designs a worthy and notable handle.
05/15/2015 DJ Mueller
Too cool. You will sell-out your inventory within the first hours at Handworks, with massive back orders to follow.
05/15/2015 Stan King
That is a fine looking saw! Can't wait to get my hands on it, reserve one for me.
05/15/2015 Thomas Wilson
A saw this size is what I have been wanting for a while now.This looks great for fast ripping, sign me up for one.
05/15/2015 Niels Cosman
WOAH!!!
That's a radical saw handsaw! I can't wait to get my hands on one!
That etch looks absolutely gorgeous!
What's the handle wood? Cherry?
What tooth configurations will you be offering?
05/15/2015 Marv Werner (MarvW)
Ok, Where's the NIB?

Is it 8 teeth per inch or 8 points per inch?

What are the holes for?

Will you be offering traditional crosscut teeth?

What is the over-all length?

It appears to be a roughing saw?

Will you be doing the sharpening of the teeth?

It appears to be about 14" from the toe end to the front of the handle. Seems a bit short on one end.
05/16/2015 Craig Lee
I WANT ONE !!!!! as soon as they are available, please :)
some of the saws I have found either on the internet or locally seem to lack any care about craftsmanship in finish or assembly that result in low performance or outright garbage, of course I am preaching to the "choir" here but I am not afraid good money for good tools and I am strictly a non-professional wood worker (hobby woodworker sounds so dismissave). look forward to this saw's release for cosumption.
16"
the handle is hickory
we will offer sharpening, but it;s not that hard to do yourself
the holes are for angle layout
at this time we don't have plans for other tooth configurations
the reception at handworks was a amazing
More soon - I'm wiped from the shop.
05/17/2015 Gavin
Interesting concept. Are you able to share how you shape the teeth?
05/17/2015 Sylvain
This looks very interesting.

Is the superior performance due to extra space for the saw-dust in the notches?

Marvellous etching but...
You say: "In the next weeks we will release the saw to the world."
Do you mean to Liberia?
Because obviously it is not metric ;-)

Sylvain
Sylvain,
No worries the other side of the saw is all metric.
joel
05/18/2015 Charles Stanford
Finally, something interesting in the saw plate and not just somebody's take on a pretty handle. I'm going to buy one.
05/28/2015 John
I can't wait for this to be released so I can get one. It looks like a perfect shop saw.
06/14/2015 Wes Faulkenberry, Jr.
Bump! Any up-dates, Joel? I really could use this saw in a couple of weeks, if possible. Thanks.
06/26/2015 John
When are you guys going to release this saw? I've got some money burning a hole in my pocket...
August 1
06/27/2015 John
Thanks, Joel!
07/04/2015 Wes Faulkenberry, Jr.
August 1st? The day after my birthday? PERFECT! Honey?....Are you reading this? ;-)
Comments are closed.
The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the blog's author and guests and in no way reflect the views of Tools for Working Wood.