Tools for Working Wood

 Joel's Blog at Tools for Working Wood

Match That Workbench Contest  

05/24/2010

With lots of interest in early workbenches infiltrating the blogs of Chris Schwarz and Peter Follansbee I started writing my own entry on some workbench observations I had (which will appear soon). In the process of research I looked through the Diderot Encyclopedia (1751- 1777) to see what they had to say. Lots of workbenches, sort of all the same, but sort of different. The only common thread I see is they all seem to use a lot of holdfasts. Anyway before I comment on anything I thought it might be fun to have a little contest. Prize: 1 holdfast delivered free anywhere in the USA. All you have to do is post a comment that matches up the picture letters to the craft numbers. The contest will be open for three days after this post at which time I'll post a winner. Post your answers as a comment. First correct answer wins. Remember: Looking up the answers in Diderot is CHEATING - so don't do it.

Here are 7 pictures of workbenches, and twelve trades. MATCH THEM UP!!!! (it's not easy and I have cropped the pictures to remove obvious clues and of course you have some extra trades here just to confuse everything).







AB
CD
EF
G
Choices:
1 - Box Making
2 - Cabinetmaking and Marquetry
3 - Carpentry (as distinct from joinery)
4 - Carriage Making
5 - Case Making
6 - Chest, Case, and Trunk Making
7 - Clog Making (wooden shoes)
8 - Framing (pictures)
9 - Joinery, Cabinetmaking and Marquetry
10 - Musical Instrument Making (Lutherie)
11 - Wood Engraver
12 - Sawyer (lumber trades)


PS. Sorry for the distortion in the photos - the pages weren't flat - the workbenches are.


Tags:Product News, Sales, and Promotions,Historical Subjects
Comments: 15
05/24/2010Bob 
Fun idea!
1:D
2:E
3:C
4:F
5:
6:B
7:
8:
9:G
10:
11:
12:A
05/24/2010Michael D. 
Not positive, but it's always worth to gander a guess!

a-12 b-2 c-4 d-3 e-1 f-5 g-9
05/24/2010Al R. 
A:1
B:8
C:3
D:10
E:4
F:11
G:2

My poor guesses, but what the heck....
05/24/2010Mike M. 
Great blog, here are my guesses (and it is guessing completely).

A-12, B-2, C-3, D-5, E-10, F-11, G-9.
05/24/2010Jamie Bacon http://www.planeshavings.blogspot.com
Nice engravings. Tough contest, but here goes:

a-6, b-10, c-11, d-4, e-3, f-8, g-9
05/24/2010Badger http://badgerwoodworks.com
I'm looking forward to the post, those are some great shots of workbenches.

Here are guesses.

A - 6 - Chest, Case, and Trunk Making
B - 10 - Musical Instrument Making (Lutherie)
C - 2 - Cabinetmaking and Marquetry
D - 4 - Carriage Making
E - 3 - Carpentry (as distinct from joinery)
F - 11 - Wood Engraver
G - 9 - Joinery, Cabinetmaking and Marquetry
05/24/2010Stuart Hough 
Here goes!
A:5
B:8
C:12
D:10
E:6
F:1
G:9
05/25/2010Marty Reser 
A-3,B-2,C-12,D-5,E-9,F-10,G-6????
05/25/2010Andrew Gibson 
a=9
b=10
c=12
d=8
e=9
f=1
g=2

This is hard. I would be suprised if I got any of them right.
05/26/2010D.Kull 
a-4
b-10
c-12
d-9
e-2
f-11
g-3
05/26/2010D.McCammon 
a-1
b-2
c-11
d-5
e-4
f-9
g-6
05/26/2010Steve Kay 
A - 2
B - 1
C - 4
D - 10
E - 9
F - 5
G - 6
05/26/2010Eric 
A - 6
B - 1
C - 4
D - 5
E - 2
F - 11
G - 9
05/27/2010Mark smith 
a.3
b.8
c.12
d.4
e.6
f.11
g.9
05/28/2010joel http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com
THE CONTEST IS CLOSED!!!
good luck to all the contestants, I will post an answer key and announce a winner over the weekend in a new blog entry.
Comments are closed.
The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the blog's author and guests and in no way reflect the views of Tools for Working Wood.
Subscribe
 Joel's Blog
 Built-It Blog
 Work Magazine
 Classes & Events
Recent Blogs:
Gabba Gabba Hey!-08/17/2016
Summer News!-08/10/2016
The Unisphere-08/03/2016
The Joiner and Cabinetmaker - Free Downloads-07/27/2016
Chisel Detective-07/13/2016
Chairs from China-07/06/2016
Architectural Woodwork and a Look at Thomas Moser-06/29/2016
Two New Books for Tool Collectors-06/22/2016
Which Festool Sander Should I Get? - Updated-06/15/2016
A Thrilling Visit to the Pennsylvania Academy of The Fine Arts-06/08/2016
Physical Graffiti-06/01/2016
Sharpening With Diamond Stones - Conclusions-05/25/2016
YouTube: Woodworking In Asia-05/18/2016
Dust Collection - Which Festool Vacuum Should I Get - Demo Day This Saturday-05/11/2016
The Saw-Book Quarterly January 1903-05/04/2016
Big Discounts on Festool Vacuums, Demo Days, and Sharpening Classes, and Surprise Sale Bin Stuff -04/27/2016
The Old Merchant's House-04/20/2016
Festool All Brilliant Abrasives and 15V Cordless Drills Being Discontinued-04/13/2016
Six Reasons Why You Have Trouble Getting a Razor Sharp Edge-04/06/2016
Maurice Fraser 1928-2016 RIP-03/30/2016
Older Entries...