Tools for Working Wood

 Joel's Blog

Winning An Uphill Battle With Your Saw  

12/07/2009

I see a lot of people using a western style (cut on push) dovetail saw having trouble starting the cut and then continuing smoothly onwards. The reason almost never has to do with the saw. Most people seem start a cut with the saw resting on the trailing edge of the work (fig 1). This is due to a combination of the height of the average workbench and the hang of the typical mid-19th century style repro dovetail saw. Then they find the saw hard to start and, even after starting, jumping in the cut. This is true even is they first form a groove in the wood by pulling backwards on the saw. The reason is that wood is composed of a bunch of fibers and by starting on the training edge of the work they are cutting "downhill" directly into the fibers of the wood, which want to stick up, catch, and in general cause trouble. It's like rubbing a dog's fur the wrong way. It's exactly like trying to plane against the grain of the wood.

Just for jollies try starting a cut on the leading edge. It may take holding the saw tilted up more, although with a traditional 18th century pattern saw with a high hang and cant to the blade it will be easier. The difference will be immediately apparent. Instead of trying to splinter off the end of lots of fibers of wood, you are planing "uphill" and shaving off fibers of wood with the grain. The saw will start easier and cut smoother. Don't take my word for it. Got to the shop and try this out. I'll still be here when you get back.

Ok. You see how much easier it is to start a cut and continue sawing.

Now when I saw I hold the saw with the back about level (I can only see the back when I look down)(fig 3). The cant on the blade gives me just a little tilt up. Push the saw forward with no downward pressure and the cut is started. This also works because a hand filed, all the points of the saw distributed the force and it is less likely for any single tooth to catch. However even with a stock, inexpensive machine made saw you will see an instant benefit from starting on the leading edge, sawing "uphill".

I should mention that with Japanese pull saws there is the same tendency to start on the trailing edge of the wood, but since you are pulling the saw towards you you are effectively cutting on the "uphill" with the same smooth result, just like cutting on the leading edge with a push saw.
I should also mention that some makers of western saws add a lot of negative rake to the saw teeth to mitigate this problem. This makes the saw smoother to start but you lose a speed advantage of having a more aggressive tooth. By holding the saw at the correct attack angle to the wood you can have a saw filed with zero rake cut very smooth and very fast.
Tags:Woodworking Tools and Techniques
Comments: 2
12/07/2009PeteW 
Good tip, Joel. But just to be sure I've understood this properly, you're talking about rip cuts in endgrain, right? I know you mention the dovetail saw, but I'm guessing this applies to any rip saw and any kind of rip cut - long rips, dovetails, tenons, etc.
12/10/2009JOHN DIXON 
Joel, If you place your forearm on a flat surface (bench top) and then place a dovetail saw in your hand, the saw naturally takes the position of pointing up hill. I suspect they were designed this way, because this is the way you are meant to begin a cut. Try to begin the cut for the pin of a half-blind dovetail any other way. So why not use the same method for all cuts. Less for the ageing to hold onto.
Comments are closed.
The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the blog's author and guests and in no way reflect the views of Tools for Working Wood.
Subscribe
 Joel's Blog
 Video Roundup
 Classes & Events
 Built-It Blog
 Work Magazine
Recent Blogs:
Plane Spotting for the Deeply Curious - 05/24/2017
A Sense of Community - 05/17/2017
Amana Here We Come! - 05/10/2017
OMG - 16th Century Boxwood Miniatures PT2 - and other news - 05/03/2017
OMG - 16th Century Boxwood Miniatures PT1 - and other news - 04/26/2017
Spooncarving and News - 03/29/2017
How to Use a Marking or Mortise Gauge (reprise) - 03/22/2017
How to Learn to Carve in the Modern Age - The Online Approach - 03/15/2017
Mitre Planes and the Finest of Mouths: Why? What Evidence? What to Look for When Shopping for Mitre and Shoulder Planes - 03/08/2017
Context! - 03/01/2017
Mitre Planes and an Observation about Maker's Marks - 02/22/2017
How To Grind Part 6 - How to Repair a Damaged Edge Without Burning the Steel - 02/08/2017
How To Grind: Part 5 - Grinding the Hollow - 02/01/2017
How To Grind: Part 4 - Dressing Your Grinding Wheel for Cool Running, Balance, and Convexity - 01/25/2017
How To Grind Part 3 - Grinding Wheel Chemistry and Nomenclature - 01/19/2017
How To Grind Part 2 - The Technology of Grinding -, Grinders, and Grinding Wheels - 01/11/2017
How To Grind - Part 1 - When To Grind - 01/04/2017
Happy New Year, A Great Experience, Ideas for the New Year, & News - 12/28/2016
Nail - 12/21/2016
The Gramercy Tools Saw Etch Story - 12/14/2016
Older Entries...